THE Finishing Touch | Plus: Thanksgiving's 2 Biggest Pain Points, Addressed


Friends, good morning ☀️

Last week, when my 11-year-old saw the freshly baked squash pie on the counter, she turned to me, eyes wide: "Any whipped cream?"

I hadn't planned on making any, since the pie is delicious on its own and the only reason I made this one a week before Thanksgiving was to see if I could produce a crack-free custard.

But I obliged.

I decided I would take the opportunity to quantify how much confectioners' sugar and flaky sea salt I actually use per cup of heavy cream. Before I began, I quickly Googled "whipped cream recipes" and, no surprise, found a wide range of sugar amounts, but more surprisingly, found that not one of them included salt.

No salt!

Friends, salted whipped cream is where it is at: salt heightens the flavor of the cream, sugar, and vanilla, and salted whipped cream better balances all the sweetness of whatever it’s paired with.

I've added my recipe to the blog, which will yield about 4 cups of billowy soft, slightly sweet, and nicely salted whipped cream for all of your Thanksgiving pie needs (and beyond 🎉).

I am wishing you all a wonderful final weekend of planning and prepping. I no doubt will be in touch one last time before the big feast, but if I am not, Happy Thanksgiving! Enjoy your time with your friends and family. Grateful for all of you 🙏

PS: Last year, the day after Thanksgiving, I made Turkey Tetrazzini for the first time to use up some of our leftover turkey. It was such a hit, I made it again the next night. If you're already thinking about leftovers, this is a great one to add to your recipe arsenal.


Review of the Week

​Sweet Potato Casserole​

​⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️​

"I have made this recipe multiple times, and it is fabulous! There is never any left over after gatherings."

— Hanna


Thanksgiving's Two Biggest Pain Points

Pie Dough and Gravy.

Pie talk first. Without question, the comments and emails I receive most often this time of year pertain to pie dough.

All of my pie-dough-making and parbaking wisdom is included in this post, but to review, I think the keys to success include:

  • Making the dough ahead of time (which allows the flour to fully hydrate and the gluten to relax, making it easier to roll out. A relaxed dough is also less likely to shrink in the oven).
  • Chilling the shaped pie crust before baking.
  • Using more pie weights than you think. (I use 3.5 lbs of rice/beans per pie and pile them above the rim of the dough.)
  • And finally, relying on visual cues (faint browning at the edges and bottom).

Make-Ahead Gravy

Another great source of Thanksgiving anxiety is the gravy. Making gravy isn't hard, but when you are trying to finish up various dishes or reheat others while the bird rests, having to make gravy on top of that is a lot.

The solution? Make it ahead of time! This week, after making my stock, I made the gravy. On Thanksgiving, I'll transfer the gravy to a pot, simmer it slowly, and when the bird emerges from the oven, I'll fortify the stock with the pan drippings. This is a very simple recipe, but so rich and flavorful, too:


The Final Countdown!

Less than a week away — the countdown is on. Here are two Google Docs you can copy and adapt to your own needs/schedules:

Here's my annual Thanksgiving Post.

You'll find recipes for my favorite stuffings, potatoes, pies, rolls, sauces, sides, and more 🦃


I Am So Looking Forward To:

​Stuffing!​

And more stuffing:

​Potatoes!

And More Potatoes:

​Buttermilk Pull-Apart Rolls:

​Red Wine Cranberry Sauce​

​Butternut Squash Pie​

​​Sister Pie's Salted Maple Pie​

​​Pecan Pie (No Corn Syrup)​

Happy Thanksgiving, Friends! 🦃🦃🦃🦃



Thank You

Thank you to all who have ordered Pizza Night. If you haven't left a review yet, I would be so grateful if you did! 🙏🙏🍕🍕🥗🥗


5 Free Resources Available to You

PS: All previous editions of this newsletter are available here.

Hi. I'm Ali.

Bread enthusiast. Vegetable lover. Omnivore. If the kitchen is your happy place, you're in good company. Let's hang.

Read more from Hi. I'm Ali.

Friends, good morning 🥧 About this time last year, I went on a quest to figure out why my pumpkin pie always cracks and how to prevent it. The most common culprit, I learned, was over-baking. One solution I found said to use an instant-read thermometer to test the pie's temperature and remove it when it registered between 175ºF and 200ºF. The pie, I read, should look jiggly in the center. Hopeful, I made a pie and diligently tested it with my Javelin every 5 minutes starting at the 45-minute...

Friends, hello. Recently, I came across a recipe for mashed potatoes that calls for 18 tablespoons of butter. While I'm not afraid of butter, this felt unnecessary, and it reminded me of the genius of Sally Schneider's recipe, which calls for a mere one tablespoon of butter. If one tablespoon of butter for mashed potatoes sounds austere, I hear you, but every time I make her recipe, I am astonished there is no cream and very little butter — they taste far richer than they actually are. To...

Friends, good morning ☀️ One of the most frequently asked questions I receive is whether this sourdough bread recipe can be baked into rolls. I'm sure it could, but rolls, at least the pull-apart variety, call for a slightly different formula, namely a few enrichments to make them soft and pillowy. I've finally added a sourdough dinner roll recipe to the blog. Inspired by this favorite buttermilk pull-apart roll recipe, this one includes a little melted butter, a little sweetener (honey), and...