The Genius of Sally Schneider's Mashed Potatoes


Friends, hello.

Recently, I came across a recipe for mashed potatoes that calls for 18 tablespoons of butter. While I'm not afraid of butter, this felt unnecessary, and it reminded me of the genius of Sally Schneider's recipe, which calls for a mere one tablespoon of butter.

If one tablespoon of butter for mashed potatoes sounds austere, I hear you, but every time I make her recipe, I am astonished there is no cream and very little butter — they taste far richer than they actually are.

To review, Sally uses buttermilk instead of heavy cream or milk, which she prefers for its natural creaminess but lower fat content. She also incorporates the potato-cooking liquid to thin the mash as needed. Finally, only after the potatoes have absorbed the liquid does Sally add that single tablespoon of butter.

By adding the butter at the end, she says, “the butter stays on the surface of the potatoes, its flavor readily discernible, imparting a truly rich finish.”

Many of you likely have your tried-and-true mashed potato recipe, but if you don't, I implore you to give these a go. They don't taste like diet food, and they never fail to receive rave reviews (even from children who love the rich and creamy variety served at steakhouses and BBQ joints far and wide).

Two more tips:

  • Yukon gold potatoes make for an especially creamy mash.
  • A food mill or ricer makes for an especially light, smooth texture.

As always, Friends, I hope you love them. 'Til tomorrow 👋

PS: I finally made a crack-free pumpkin (butternut squash) pie. I will share the details tomorrow.

PPS: I use my food mill to make applesauce: 2 ingredients, 20 minutes, so delicious.


Thank You

Thank you to all who have ordered Pizza Night. If you haven't left a review yet, I would be so grateful if you did! 🙏🙏🍕🍕🥗🥗


5 Free Resources Available to You

PS: All previous editions of this newsletter are available here.

Hi. I'm Ali.

Bread enthusiast. Vegetable lover. Omnivore. If the kitchen is your happy place, you're in good company. Let's hang.

Read more from Hi. I'm Ali.

Friends, good morning ☀️ One of the most frequently asked questions I receive is whether this sourdough bread recipe can be baked into rolls. I'm sure it could, but rolls, at least the pull-apart variety, call for a slightly different formula, namely a few enrichments to make them soft and pillowy. I've finally added a sourdough dinner roll recipe to the blog. Inspired by this favorite buttermilk pull-apart roll recipe, this one includes a little melted butter, a little sweetener (honey), and...

*Simple Soft Sourdough rolls... coming soon! Friends, good morning. Earlier this week at the grocery store, I passed a large cooler in the aisle filled with turkeys. I know it is late October. I know the holiday season is upon us. But still, somehow Thanksgiving always creeps up. Feeling slightly panicky, I did what any anxious girl would do: I made my pie dough! A double batch! And I think you should, too. Friends, won't it feel so good to check off this to-do? To go to sleep tonight knowing...

Friends, hello. I'm popping into your inbox today quickly with a reminder: If you make your pizza dough tonight, you can have a pizza party tomorrow 🍕🍕🎉🎉 And if you're having a pizza party, have you considered making pan pizza? And specifically grandma pizza? I can't sing its praises enough: The focaccia-style dough is effortless to make. It does not require delicate handling or skilled shaping. No parbake. You can assemble the pizzas hours ahead of time and bake them as needed. They reheat...