Turkey Tetrazzini-ish {New} + The Prettiest Applesauce + Thanksgiving Recap


Friends, hello!

I hope you all had a wonderful Thanksgiving. We spent it at my parents' house in Connecticut with my sister's family and my brother and sister-in-law. It was a treat to all be together, and, as always, the time passed too quickly. By Friday afternoon, we had all scattered in different directions, and the weekend madness had begun.

Yesterday, before leaving, I made turkey tetrazzini, a variation of a recipe for chicken tetrazzini one of you had emailed me a few months ago. I had never made or eaten turkey or chicken tetrazzini before yesterday, but as I've now learned, there are many, many ways to make it. This one calls for sautéeing mushrooms and making a sort of bechamel/gravy, which you toss with pasta (typically spaghettini), leftover chicken or turkey, and parmesan, and then bake until bubbly.

I used maitake mushrooms, which I love for their easy prep: you can essentially break them into pieces — no cleaning or chopping required. And they brown up beautifully:

The assembly is simple: toss together the parcooked pasta (I used penne), sautéed mushrooms, leftover turkey, and bechamel/gravy:

Top with parmesan:

Bake till bubbly:

I'm sharing this recipe in a Google Doc as opposed to on the blog, as I've only made it once. It is such a great way to use up leftovers — leftover turkey, leftover turkey stock — and it is so, so delicious. If you give it a go, I'd love to hear how you like it.

A few Thanksgiving highlights:

The kids' table:

A (minimally cracked 🎉) butternut squash pie:

Salted Maple Pie:

Rolls + pies:


The Prettiest Applesauce

A few weeks ago I asked my friend Jake Samascott (of Samascott Orchards), which apple he would suggest using if I wanted to make a brilliantly hued sauce, and he said without hesitation: Jonathan. He was not wrong. Look at that hue! The sauce is made with nothing more than apples and water, and it is so, so tasty. I made a double batch before heading to CT on Wednesday morning, and we served it at Thanksgiving. It, along with the cranberry sauce, was such a nice complement to everything on the plate.


Review of the Week

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Simple Classic Shortbread

"I may have already rated this recipe, but I’ll do it again! This is delicious and absolutely foolproof. It is a perfect anytime kind of treat. I’ve made it three times in the last month! Thank you!"

— Jessica


5 More Recipes to Make This Weekend

Perhaps another batch of buttermilk pull-apart rolls to satisfy your leftover turkey sandwich needs? You might need to make another batch of cranberry sauce, too.

A freezer meal, but with turkey subbed in for the chicken:

Addictive Black Lentils with Spinach ... only when you've polished off all of your leftovers.

Vermont Cheddar Cheese Soup... my mother had a vat of this in her fridge when we were visiting, and we all feasted on it for lunch during our few days in CT... soooo good.

Marcella Hazan's Stewy White Beans... delicious, beany comfort food.


Popular Right Now

You Are Loving These 3 Recipes...

PS: ALL the popular recipes right here → Popular Recipes

PPS: Perfectly Moist Pumpkin Bread... tis the season 🎃

Thank You

Thank you to all who have ordered Pizza Night. If you haven't left a review yet, I would be so grateful if you did! 🙏🙏🍕🍕🥗🥗


5 Free Resources Available to You

PS: All previous editions of this newsletter can be found here.

Hi. I'm Ali.

Bread enthusiast. Vegetable lover. Omnivore. If the kitchen is your happy place, you're in good company. Let's hang.

Read more from Hi. I'm Ali.

Pie Dough and Gravy. Pie talk first. Without question, the comments and emails I receive most often this time of year relate to pie dough. This week, upon finding a disk of pie dough in my vegetable bin, I found myself with my own question. It looked a little gray, but it smelled fine. It was at least 2 weeks old. Hmmm, I wondered. Is it OK to use? Let's find out. I rolled it out: Pinched and chilled it: Then parbaked it: Friends, it was as flaky and crisp and buttery as ever! Phew. All of my...

Friends, Greetings from Buffalo 👋 I have been here since Thursday evening, of course, for hockey, and while the games in the outdoor rinks have been thrilling, can I tell you the highlight thus far? I spotted turkey wings at Wegmans! I have yet to purchase them because I thought it might be weird to store 5 pounds of turkey parts in my hotel fridge, but I will be returning to my favorite Western New York store before heading home tomorrow, and my only goal for the evening will be to get those...

You are getting organized 🎉 You are making your grocery list. Drafting your timeline. Stocking up on the essentials. And maybe, if you're like my sister anyway, you're setting your table. (Truly, she sets her Thanksgiving table 3 weeks ahead of time.) Here are two Google Docs you can copy and adapt to your own needs/schedules: Countdown to Thanksgiving 2025 Thanksgiving 2025 Grocery List This week, I broke out my largest bowl, one I can't recommend enough (if you have the space to store it),...